Fatwa ID: 21500
Title: Certainty
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: AMJAonline Jurisprudence Section
Date: 03/19/2008

Question

May the peace, mercy and blessing of Allah be upon you.

 

I am exceedingly grateful and blessed, not only because of your noble response, your time and the effort you put forth, but also because of the elevated style in which you answer detailed enquiries. I benefited enormously from your valuable response to my questions, in particular, the logical way of thinking on the necessary nature of the existence of Allah. However, if science and natural inclination (fitra) prove that it is impossible for this universe to exist without a creator, then what does science say about the existence of the Creator, Allah, the Mighty and Majestic, without a creator? Despite my conviction that it is a silly, trivial train of thought to wonder who created Allah, and then, who created the one who created Allah, is the solution not to think and just to say I believe in Allah? Also, is it really easy to think that there is a First without beginning? Is that really logical?

 

The second part I find it difficult for my mind or my heart to get is how we will live forever after we are raised back from the dead. I think it seems more logical that when we die, it's over. This [doubt] prevents me from being able to make du`a (informal prayer or supplication) or ask [Allah] for forgiveness, due to the absence of certainty (yaqin) in all of my acts of worship, which in turn, has made me lose hope of any reward due to my uncertainty about the utility of these deeds.

 

[Also,] is the strength with which the Messenger of Allah (saws) is described different than the lustful desire the enemies of Islam accuse our noble prophet of and which our scholars of fiqh negate in defense of our prophet?

 

May Allah grant you every reward and may the peace, mercy and blessing of Allah be upon you.


Answer

To the sister asking:

 

May Allah reward you well for this praise which only befits someone of noble character. We hope that Allah will accept from us any deed done sincerely for His Glorious Countenance and that He put us to good use and not replace us.

 

Regarding the first part of the question:

 

What comes before zero? Zero!

What is before the origin of matter? Matter!

What is before nothingness? Nothingness!

 

Your mind accepts these obvious facts and yet doesn't accept that there is nothing before the Creator but the Creator?!

 

Allah Most High, there is no beginning before Him, because (in simple terms), He Himself is the Beginning.

 

Just as your mind accepts that Allah has no end, it can be content with the knowledge that He has no beginning.

 

This is the essence of logic, and if not, then prove that there is a hidden creator who created Allah and that that creator has not and will not make himself known, and through logic!

 

Believe me, this subject is from the evil suggestions of the Devil and it has no relation to sound, rational thought. Our Messenger has guided us to the straightforward solution to [this dilemma], without getting into philosophical rationalizations like before! We have what is more important.

 

 

Contemplate the greatness and practicality of our religion:

 

A man came to the Prophet (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) asking about the (Final) Hour, and what was his answer? Was it:

 

1. "I'm not going to tell you" (!)

2. "The Hour will be in so-many years" (!)

3. Ignoring him (!)

 

No, it wasn't. Rather, he responded with (as the scholars call it) "the answer of a wise man".

 

His "beneficial" answer was, "And what have you prepared for it?"

 

Thus, he guided him (in a very practical way) to that which would really be of benefit to him in his religion and that was the point.

 

I, in turn, say to you: Do not ask about things in which there is no reward. Put your effort and reason to use in things that will actually be of benefit to you, especially if the issue is settled!

 

The second part:

 

If you mean by your question that you doubt the physical resurrection after death, then, verily, the sound mind rejects [such doubt] on two points:

 

First: Justice (Balance)

Divine Justice (or Balance), on which the heavens and the earth were established, that which you see in the distribution of worldly provision, the scope and scale of all things and the amazing cosmic balance, extending from the nucleus of an atom to the greatest galaxies in the universe; all of this affirms the Saying of Allah Most High (in meaning),

 

"Verily, We have created all things with Qadr,"

[Al-Qamar 54:49]

 

Qadr, meaning calculated proportion and order. So how can you imagine that the criminal would be on the same level as the true believers, the hypocrite with the sincere, and the evil-doer with the doers of good deeds, by nothing other than the end of their lives in this world?

 

Moreover, does it make sense that the end of a human life should be the same as the life of a fly?! Verily, the Justice of Allah Most High and sound human logic scream: No by Allah! They are not equal!

 

So, how can we doubt in life after death which leads to man reaping what he has sown with his own hand, so that the good person gets his reward, and the bad person, his punishment?

 

Secondly: The Power of Allah

Allah Most High has given marvelous examples in His Noble Book [the Qur'an] to prove this truth. I will leave you a while to contemplate, calmly, slowly and deeply, the Words of our Creator, the Glorious and Exalted (in meaning),

 

Does not man see that We have created him from a drop of semen? Yet behold! He (stands forth) as an open opponent.

 

And he puts forth for Us a parable, and forgets his own creation. He says, "Who will give life to these bones when they have rotted away and become dust?"

 

Say, (O Muhammad), "He will give life to them Who created them the first time! And He is the All-Knower of every creation!"

 

He, Who produces for you fire out of the green tree, when behold! You kindle therewith.

 

Is not He, Who created the heavens and the earth, Able to create the like of them? Yes, indeed! He is the All-Knowing, Supreme Creator.

 

Verily, His Command, when He intends a thing, is only that He says to it, "Be!" –and it is!

 

So glorified be He and exalted above all that they associate with Him, and in Whose Hands is the dominion of all things, and to Him you shall be returned.

 

[Surat Ya-Sin 36: 77-83]

 

If your doubt is in the eternal life of the human being, on the other hand, then, verily, the soul does not die and He Who created it from nothing is Able, with the greatest of ease, to make it immortal. The mind and the heart both admit to the Power of Allah Most High; neither finds any difficulty with His Ability to grant the soul immortality.

 

If you believe in the Resurrection, you must necessarily believe that you will be rewarded for all of your actions, from salat (formal prayer), to charity, to any good deed. That is a firm guarantee from the Lord of the Worlds (Allah).

 

Allah Most High has said (in meaning),

 

So, whoever does good equal to the weight of an atom (or a small ant), shall see it.

 

And whosoever does evil equal to the weight of an atom (or a small ant), shall see it.

[Surat al-Zalzalah 99: 7-8]

 

If you still doubt the utility of your actions, I remind you again of the theory of the fly!

 

Concerning the strength, or "virility," of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah bless him and grant him peace), it is complete, comprehensive strength, meaning that it is not particular to conjugal connotations alone. Rather, it encompasses every aspect of human strength, both spiritual and physical, for his companions used to take cover with him when the fighting intensified and he never used to be defeated in any physical confrontation. Likewise, he was strong in truth, opinion, determination and length of worship.

 

Just as it is not appropriate for us to describe Prophet Solomon as lustful, it is not correct to do so with the best of all creation (Muhammad), may the peace and blessing of Allah be upon him. In general, attacks on manhood come from those who lack it.

 

Each of his marriages had a well-founded purpose. One of his wives he married because her husband left Islam and became an apostate. Another he married to free her people from slavery. A third he married to bring down the tradition of adoption amongst the Arabs. And so on… In addition to that, a man is not blamed for his desire for women, as long as it is within the bounds of Shari`ah. On the contrary, it is in fact one of the necessary components of strength and masculinity. In fact, the Prophet (saws) stated clearly and unabashedly, "[Two things] of your world have been made beloved to me: scent and women." [Reported by an-Nasa'i] This is truly the innate nature of man.

 

Of course, the strength of the Prophet (saws) differs from his desire, for in one night, he used to be able to go around to all of his wives, but then, on other nights, he would stand in prayer between the Hands of his Lord (Allah) until his feet would crack (may Allah bless him and grant him peace). So why do they cling to the first meaning and ignore the second?

 

I ask you now: Have you stood the last third of the night, praying and beseeching your Lord as I invited you to before? Or has your business with these matters prevented you from such precious moments?

 

May Allah reward you well…

 

And all praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds.