Fatwa ID: 21695
Title: The verdict of a disbeliever who dies on disbelief
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 01/29/2008

Question

To the honorable shaikh, Dr. Salah al-Sawi, may Allah preserve him:

 

Peace be upon you. I would like to know the belief of Ahlus-Sunnah on a known disbeliever who we know died on disbelief, such as Pope John Paul II of the Vatican. Can we say that this Pope is in the Hellfire, for eternity, or would it be better that we not get into the matter?

 

May Allah reward you and may the peace, mercy and blessing of Allah be upon you.


Answer

May the peace, mercy and blessing of Allah be upon you also.

 

All praise is due to Allah and may peace and blessing be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, companions and whoever follows his guidance. To proceed:

 

The general ruling is that whoever dies on disbelief is in the Hellfire, but that does not mean that we should judge an individual and testify that a particular person is in Hell, and likewise, Heaven. On that basis, it is not permissible to testify that a specific individual is in Heaven or in Hell, except those about whom Allah has born witness to this in His Noble Book (the Qur'an) or those about whom His Messenger (saws) bore witness in his authentic Sunnah. We bear witness that the people of true faith (ahl ul-iman) in general are in Heaven and the disbelievers in general are in Hell. This is because what is taken into consideration are the final endings and that is something no one sees but Allah Almighty, the Knower of the Unseen and the Visible. As such, we should take the saying of anyone who specifies [that so-and-so is in Hell] to mean, "…if he died on disbelief," even if that is not actually stated. Therefore, the more cautious and blameless position and that which is closer to the truth is not to judge or testify that a specific person is in Heaven or Hell (as long as there is no textual evidence for that), except with the cautionary qualifier: "…if he died on that."

 

Among the evidence for this statement:

 

1 - The Saying of Allah Almighty (in meaning),

{And whosoever of you turns back from his religion and dies as a disbeliever, then his deeds will be lost in this life and in the Hereafter, and they will be the dwellers of the Fire. They will abide therein forever.}

[Al-Baqarah 2:217]

 

2 – Allah's Words (in meaning),

{And of no effect is the repentance of those who continue to do evil deeds until death faces one of them and he says, "Now, I repent;" nor of those who die while they are disbelievers. For them We have prepared a painful torment.}

[Al-Nisaa' 4:18]

 

3 – From the Sunnah, there is the saying of the Prophet (saws), " …For, verily, a man does the deeds of the dwellers of the Fire until there is no longer but an arm's length between him and it, and then the book precedes him [what has been written for him decides his behavior] and he does the deeds of the dwellers of Paradise, and so he enters it; and verily, a man does the deeds of the dwellers of Paradise until there is no more than an arms' length between him and it, and then the book precedes him and he does the deeds of the dwellers of the Fire, and so he enters it…" [Agreed upon]

 

4 – Al-Baihaqi transmitted in his book, Al-Shu`ab, on the authority of Anas (may Allah be pleased with him), "One of our men was martyred on the Day of Uhud, and we found a stone tied to his belly from hunger, so his mother wiped the dust from his face and said, 'May you enjoy it, son of the Garden (Heaven).' So, the Prophet (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) said, 'How do you know? Perhaps he used to speak of that which did not concern him and prevent that which would do him no harm." [The hadith is hasan li ghairihi (good with support) as classed by Shaikh al-Albani (may Allah bestow mercy upon him).]

 

Therefore, what would prevent us from not asserting authoritatively [an individual's fate]? And what would be difficult about qualifying our statement by saying: "…if he died on that"? For that would be more cautious and freer from blame.

 

And Allah Almighty is more Exalted and more Knowledgeable.