Fatwa ID: 21826
Title: About the differences between Sharia Scholars
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Shaykh Waleed Basyouni PhD
Date: 04/11/2005

Question

In the name of Allah the Beneficent the Merciful

Peace, blessings and mercy of Allah be upon you.

The following question which I will ask you soon, has already been raised by me to one of the contemporary thinkers and he said to me: "You have raised a great question" then, he gave me a piece of advice, but he did not answer the question. And, also I raised it into a number of Islamic sites on the internet, but they, too, did not answer me clearly and straight. However I find excuse to them because my question, as it was said to me and as I think, it is the great question. But rejecting to answer this question clearly and honestly make those who have comprehending hearts review their opinions when they are talking about Islam as a Shari`ah way of life that was ordained by Allah the Almighty Who is perfect in Names and Epithets. The great question! And the subject of the question is the following: the differences of the great respected Shari`ah scholars… while some consider it as one of the bases of the fundamentals of the religion, others see it as one of its branches, and while some see it as perfect, others see it as abrogated, and some see it as integrated, others see it as incomplete, etc. Not only that, they even differed upon the basis of the religion and its origin and source: some see that the Quran is the predominant source, i.e. the Quran moves aside the Sunnah, others see that the Sunnah is the predominant source and it puts aside the Quran. Furthermore, even someone of them said that: "Any Quranic verse or a prophetic Sunnah contradicts our fellows` saying, then it is either misinterpreted or abrogated". The first question is: Is Allah, Who is described with the epithets of perfection, lacking the ability of illuminating His religion? How do you describe your feelings when you see the Shari`ah scholars in the same school and they did not agree on the fundamentals and the firm principles of the Shari`ah? Even, they did not agree upon the perfect verses which are the Mother of the Book, and if this is the case, how could sensible people feel secure and comfortable with the fact that a Shari`ah that is adopted by its scholars, sages, and doctors on this basis, which is revealed from Allah the Exalted Who is Perfect? My second question is: What are definitely the fundamentals and the firm believes that are agreed upon among the companions and the close followers of the prophet, prayers and peace of Allah be upon him, in the first preferred centuries of the history of Islam… these fundamentals that those who believed in them and worked on them accordingly, remained in the circle of Islam, and vice versa. Please, kindly provide me with a clear, honest and convincing answer… I want a curing reply that respects the mind and eliminates doubt and confirms the heart. I want a concise and clear answer that contains neither   ambiguities nor generalities, and an honest answer that has no illusion or falsification or being far fetched from truth, even if this was under the name of public interest. Please, accept my sincere respect and honest appreciation. O, How Exalted and Praised Be Allah! I bear witness that there is no deity Except You… I pray to you for forgiveness and unto You I repent!


Answer

In the name of Allah the Beneficent the Merciful

Peace, blessings and mercy of Allah be upon you.

Praise be to Allah, prayers and peace be upon His kind Messenger, his family members, companions and true followers until the Day of Judgment.

I pray to Allah to grant you success and conformity and to make you avoid the implicit and explicit temptations – Amen!

That the differences of the Shari`ah doctors of Fiqh and Hadith narrators in many scientific or practical issues, have their roots in scientific reasons and sublime wisdoms that necessitated them to be so, and if Allah wants to make all the texts of the two revelations – the Quran and the Sunnah – in a form that wont be accepted in comprehension except in one view, and this is not impossible for Allah to do that so! However, with His mercy and wisdom, He made some of them perfect and decisive to represent the general common mean of Faith among all Muslims (the people of the Qiblah), as well as He made some of them as hypothetical alkies which form a field of diversity of personal opinions of judgments and varying of conclusions. Allah has a supreme wisdom in this, like Being Merciful to His worshippers, and extending the scope of deducting rules and rulings from texts, besides, these differences are a bliss and a legislative Fiqh treasury which make the Muslim Ummah aware of its understanding the Shari`ah rulings and issues, and this would help realize the eternity of the Shari`ah and its validity for all time and all places. This makes the Ummah free from restricting itself to only one Shari`ah application, and if one school of thought is not enough in some time, or in some issue, the Ummah would find in other schools of Fiqh solutions, conclusions and tolerance, and this has been mentioned in the resolution adopted by the Fiqh Assembly of the Muslim World League under No. 9 for the year 1408 A.H.

This is the wisdom in this matter, then do not be frightened, and do not take the laudable deeds of the Shari`ah as a weapon to attack it, and do not care for the doubts and falsifications that are promoted by the sick-hearted people and by the whispers of the devils, because, as Allah says: "Verily Satan is an enemy to you: so treat him as an enemy. He only invites his adherents, that they may become companions of the Blazing Fire", (Quran, 35:6). Once again, we pray to Allah to grant you steadfastness on truth and the sincere determination towards sensibility – Amen! Allah knows best.

(Ruled by Professor Dr. Slalah Al-Sawy).