Fatwa ID: 21835
Title: Justifying rulings
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Shaykh Waleed Basyouni PhD
Date: 02/19/2006

Question

In the name of Allah the Beneficent the Merciful

Peace, blessings and mercy of Allah be upon you.

What are the evidences that prevent giving reasons for issuing Shari`ah rulings? Jazakumu Allahu Khairan.


Answer

In the name of Allah the Beneficent the Merciful

Peace, blessings and mercy of Allah be upon you.

Praise be to Allah, prayers and peace be upon His kind Messenger, family members, companions, and true followers until the Day of Judgment.

There is nothing that prevents giving reasons for issuing Shari`ah rulings, and analogy is an authority with the grand Four Fiqh Schools of Shari`ah, and analogy does not happen except with giving reasons to follow what is silenced about with what is articulated of in ruling, because of their sharing in the reason of that ruling. The questioner may have read some worship issues that are unreasonable in meaning, and we do not know its reason, like the Dhuhr prayer being four Rak`aat, though the Maghreb prayer is only three Rak`aat, or that fasting being in the month of Ramadan and not in the month of Sha`baan, etc, and that all rulings are the same, but this is not true. Allah knows best.