Fatwa ID: 21841
Title: Lahidiyoon and claiming to be the Mahdi
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Shaykh Waleed Basyouni PhD
Date: 07/20/2006

Question

Questions about the Lahidi who claims to be the Mahdi:

1.      They believe that the Lahidi (who they claim is the awaited Mahdi) is a messenger from Allah.

2.      These Lahidiyoon say that their Mahdi is the muhaddath (Allah speaks on his tongue) of this nation, like the noble companion and caliph, Umar, and that the muhaddath has the position of a messenger to whom revelation is sent. [translator`s note: Umar (may Allah be pleased with him) is sometimes referred to by this honorary title because, on more than one amazing, yet modest occasion, he said something brief that was later confirmed by Allah in revelation; there is no comparison, however, between this and prophecy.]

3.      They encourage, if not oblige, their followers to keep away from the people. In fact, they forbid participation in both the Friday and daily congregational prayers, accusing all imams (prayer leaders) and those praying behind them of disbelief—whoever disagrees with their manhaj (way).

4.      The following is one of their sayings that the congregation is invalid: "Today there is no congregation, no Islam." So they say one should leave whatever requires a group [meaning whatever should be done in congregation, like the daily congregational prayers (salat ul-jama`ah) with the Muslims in the mosque and the Friday congregational prayer (salat ul-jumu`a). Whoever prays them is a hypocrite (munafiq), or so they claim].

 

What is the opinion of the prodigious scholars on these defective interpretations? Does what they say have any basis in reality? We would appreciate an explanation from you for those of them who have begun to be drawn to these evil ideas that have occurred all of a sudden to religiously committed young men here in our peaceful little Iron City; and Allah is our Helper. We hope that you will answer us, so that we can put the response up in the mosque and spread it in chatrooms and on scholarly websites on the Internet. May Allah keep you strong in preserving His religion and land, and may He reward you for helping Islam and Muslims.


Answer

All praise is for Allah and may peace and blessing be upon His Messenger. To proceed:

 

Verily, whoever claims that the sending of prophets and messengers did not end with Muhammad ibn Abdillah, has come with what contradicts the basic tenets of faith in Islam. The Ummah (Nation) is united on this. As for what you mentioned about this Lahdiya sect in Yemen, I have no knowledge of the details of what they believe, but I refer you to what our sheikh, Dr. Nasir ibn Abdul-Karim al-`Aql wrote on the topic of the Mahdi on the site www.islamtoday.com. It says,

 

"All praise is for Allah alone, and may peace and blessing be on His Messenger. To proceed:

 

The Mahdi who is mentioned in detail in authentic hadiths—the Mahdi with whom the Muslims will fight the Dajjal (the Antichrist), will descend in the time of `Isa (Jesus, peace be upon him). No one knows where he will be born or where he will be from; instead, he will appear suddenly with the events at the end of time. It has come in the Sunnah that "Allah will guide him in one night." [Musnad Ahmad and Ibn Majah] He is from the lineage of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) and his name is Muhammad ibn Abdillah. It is not possible for anyone to know or foresee when he will be born or from where he will come, or where he will appear, in the sense of pinpointing the location or specifying it. Whoever claims any of this knowledge is a lying dajjal (deceiver). As for the signs of his coming, there are major and minor signs, which are of two types:

 

First: The minor signs, of which many have occurred over the course of time since the beginning of the Prophet`s mission (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) until the present time. However, there are still many that have not yet come to pass, and Allah knows best.

 

Second: The major signs, among which will be the coming of the Mahdi, are all still to come. No one can say for certain when they will happen; perhaps after decades, perhaps after centuries, or whenever Allah Most High wills, for He alone knows the unseen. The Almighty has said about the Hour, {None can reveal its time but He.} [Al-A`raf 7:187] Then, {It shall not come upon you except all of a sudden.} As for the rumors people spread that the Mahdi is here, saying that he is a particular man in a particular place, and the like, this is saying things about Allah without knowledge, {guessing about the unseen} [Al-Kahf 18:22], fabrication of lies, deceit and trickery, against which we must take precautions and warn others; and Allah knows best."

 

And Allah Almighty is more exalted and more knowledgeable.