Fatwa ID: 21842
Title: Questions from a Christian
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Shaykh Waleed Basyouni PhD
Date: 07/20/2006

Question

Hello. I am a Christian and I have read some of the articles you have written. I have ten questions which I will explain and I hope you will kindly answer them.

 

One: On the topic of heaven in Islam, why do you say that it is only for Muslims? We believe that even non-Christians may enter Paradise. Christ said that many will come from the east and the west to enter the Kingdom of Heaven, and more.

 

Two: You say that the Bible has been changed. Where, how and why? That is odd, since its commandments do not contain what would make me as a Christian believe it has been changed, for the words of Christ are true to human nature.

 

Three: Christ is neither suspect nor controversial; he did not sin, form an army or fight. He is perfect.

 

Four: You say that Paul was the one who changed Christianity. How could that be since he changed from one of those who persecuted the Christians to a pious man who believed in Christ and what he said was acceptable? How do you explain his sudden conversion if not as repentance?

 

Five: You say that Paul was able to triumph over everything Christ did on the face of the earth. Is any human being capable of triumphing over the religion of Allah?

 

Six: After Christ brought the law to the most elevated level, Muhammad brought it back to the Law of Moses and that is not befitting.

 

Seven: The Qur`an speaks about inheritance and how it should be divided amongst us. We find Christ, on the other hand, said that we should build our treasure in heaven and not be concerned about money.

 

Eight: Is it reasonable that Allah would punish a good, pious Christian because he did not accept the prophecy of Muhammad?

 

Nine: You say that Paradise contains women and houris (nymphs). Does it make sense for that to be the reward instead of the pure pleasure of seeing the countenance (face) of Allah, which is the greatest reward?

 

Ten: You say that Allah led his servants astray because another person was made to look like Christ to take his place.


Answer

Greetings to you also. Here is an answer to your enquiry in general:

 

  1. Paradise is one of the creations of Allah which He gives to whomever He pleases of His servants who worship Him alone. We believe that monotheists from previous nations will be among the people who will enter Paradise as well. As for the mission of Muhammad (may Allah bless him and grant him peace), a believer does not attain faith, nor is his monotheism valid without belief in the prophecy of Muhammad (may Allah bless him and grant him peace), as long as he has heard of him and the message has reached him. The word, "Islam," applies to every believer from previous nations, just as it applies to the followers of Muhammad (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) in particular.
  2. As for the changing of the Injil (Bible), it is too obvious and well-known to give evidence for. It cannot escape you that the authors of the four canonical gospels are virtually unknown, as are the translators of the Bible and the chain of narrators who transmitted the oral tradition from the time of Jesus (peace be upon him), let alone the contradictions found between these accounts. These are facts admitted by the scholars of Christianity themselves; we know of no one who disputes this reality. As for the claim that the contents of the Bible agree with human nature, we, the people of Islam, believe that the Bible contains some of the Speech of Allah; not all of it has been changed completely, but additions and omissions have been made, translation and interpretation has been inserted into the text, and other types of changes have occurred. Finally, the claim that Allah has a son and that He is one of three (the trinity) is one of the doctrines that is neither acceptable to human nature nor to logic.
  3. Verily, the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, was a Messenger from Allah and one of the best messengers to mankind. We believe that the position of the prophets and messengers is one of protection from error and human perfection. What you have mentioned is obvious to Muslims, just as it is our conviction concerning the rest of the prophets and messengers.
  4. The changes made to the Injil may have been made on purpose with an evil intention or they may have been done with an incorrect intention, out of ignorance. There is no doubt that Paul was not the only one responsible for the changes made to the religion of Jesus (peace be upon him), but he had a powerful hand in the matter due to his being influenced by the pagan Roman religion and Indian Buddhist philosophy (among others).
  5. This question is unclear; we do not say what you claim in any way.
  6. Muhammad (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) did not go back to the Law of Moses. On the contrary, the Law of Islam is exactly the same as all of the divine messages from Adam to Jesus—all of them call to the worship of Allah alone, who has no partner—it differs from the Law of Moses and that of other prophets in some of its details, but they all agree in general principles and legal intentions. There is no doubt that in our religion there is ease, breadth and simplicity, which is why Allah made this law comprehensive for all human beings and made it abrogate all systems of law which came before.
  7. We are a just, moderate nation. For us, money is a tool and a method. Allah has made it a way to build up the earth, and divine legislation has prohibited cheating, taking money without due right, and letting money  become a goal or object of worship instead of Allah.
  8. Yes, because whoever knows about the prophecy of Muhammad (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) is obliged to seek out his message and evaluate the truth of his prophecy. Whoever refuses to do that, preferring to remain ignorant, deserves to be punished. It is related in an authentic hadith that the Prophet (may Allah bless him and grant him peace) said, "No Jew or Christian hears about me and then does not believe in me, except that it becomes right for Allah to put him in the Hellfire."
  9. We do not say that the pleasure of Paradise is only about women; on the contrary, this is ignorance of what Islam and Muslims profess. Indeed, seeing Allah is the greatest and most elevated joy for the inhabitants of Paradise. The hour al-`ain (the women of Paradise) are one aspect of the pleasures in heaven, as is living in its gardens and palaces, drinking from its rivers and the like.
  10. The likeness of Jesus was cast onto one of his disciples and he is the one who was crucified. This is not misguidance, except for the disbelievers among the Romans and Jews who were trying to kill him, and it was a protection for Jesus. Ibn `Abbas related in an authentic hadith that one of his minor followers was the one who volunteered for this when Jesus told them that whoever accepted to bear his likeness would be granted Paradise if he was patient, so this was done with the knowledge of Jesus` disciples. For this reason, we know that for a long period of time, Jesus` disciples and followers believed that he was not the son of God or God—Allah is free of all this—but that verily, this idea was introduced to the religion of the Messiah later on. May Allah guide us all to truth and reason. In conclusion, I advise you to read the Qur`an and pray at length to your Creator to open your heart to the Truth; and I ask Allah to grant guidance and success to everyone.