Fatwa ID: 21843
Title: The difference between an extremist and one who avoid doubtful matters
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 07/20/2006

Question

What is the difference between someone who is extreme and someone who avoids doubtful matters out of fear of displeasing Allah? I ask because being extreme is a blameworthy characteristic according to the text of the hadith, "No one will be extreme in his religion except that it overcomes him." The pious avoidance of what is doubtful is mentioned as a praiseworthy characteristic in the text of the hadith, "Whoever avoids doubtful matters has purified his religion and his honor."


Answer

All praise is for Allah, and may peace and blessing be upon His Messenger, his family, companions and followers. To proceed:

 

Al-Mutashaddid (the extremist) is the one who imagines a doubt that has no basis, so he avoids what does not need to be avoided. As for the muttaqi lish-shubuhat (one who avoids doubtful matters), he is the one who avoids what is considered substantially doubtful; he is praised for assuming it to be a real probability; and we ask Allah to grant success to us all.