Fatwa ID: 21845
Title: Jama`at it-Tabligh
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr. Hatem al-Haj
Date: 08/25/2006

Question

Is the Tabligh group from Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jama`ah and is it permissible to make khurooj (going out) with them, or are they innovators so we should keep away from them, even though there are so many of them here in our country, Egypt.


Answer

All praise is for Allah, and may peace and blessing be upon the Messenger of Allah. To proceed:

 

The Tabligh are an Islamic group that specialize in making da`wah and preaching; they are from Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jama`ah in general. Its members share in calling others to Islam and conveying (tabligh) the message of the superiority of Islam to all creation, Muslims and non-Muslims. It was founded by the Indian, Shaikh Muhammad Ilyas al-Kandahlawi, who lived from 1303-1364 H.

 

Some of their good points:

 

-Sincerity, which is from the acts of the heart (`aml al-qalb) that no one can know but Allah, except that it has signs that we see amongst them; for that reason we consider them sincere people.

 

-Great enthusiasm in da`wah, going out for it, and sacrificing a lot of worldly pleasures for its sake.

 

-Good organization and obedience of their leaders, little internal conflict amongst the group and avoidance of showing off amongst themselves and with others.

 

-Good manners, humility and kindness.

 

Some of the things people consider their shortcomings, though these accusations are unfounded:

 

- Their way of talking affects visitors to the mosques—whether they are Muslims or those who have gone astray—as long as they do not harbor misconceptions, ideas or ideologies hostile or contradictory to Islam. Indeed, this type of person is not affected by them, and the members of the Tabligh group are not good at battling with evidence, debunking myths or explaining deviations that contradict the Islamic way.

 

To answer this, I would say that the Tabligh do what they are capable of; they address a broad segment of the population who need to be spoken to, for the most part, in terms of rewards and punishments. People like this might not be affected by other styles. Yes, the group is to blame if they think that their work is complete and sufficient and that they don`t need the help of others, or if they refuse to recognize others` rights and belittle their efforts.

 

- Eating and drinking in the mosques, but there is nothing in this that is blameworthy. They only do this out of love for the houses of Allah and to keep expenses to a minimum. Yes, they should be blamed if they neglect to maintain the cleanliness of the mosque or its smell, but for the most part, they do not fall short in this respect.

 

- Specifying particular days for khurooj (going out to make da`wah): This is allowed in terms of organization, just as is done in universities where people go to seek knowledge of Islamic Law, and seeking knowledge is an act of worship just like da`wah. It would only become bid`ah (innovation) if they try to claim it is part of the religion. Unfortunately, I have seen some of them try to prove, with baseless arguments, that it is like Moses going out to meet his Lord for forty days. The simplest of arguments against this is that, in saying this, they claim for themselves a share of knowledge in fiqh in terms of understanding the sources which has been lost to the rest of the Ummah.

 

- Neglecting their wives and children, some of them going out to make da`wah while their families are in dire need of them. To answer this, I would say that these stories are about individual members of the group and should not be attributed to the group as a whole unless they approve. Some of these stories are true, however, which leads one to worry and doubt whether or not these people have a sound understanding of the religion and of other people`s rights on them. We would remind such people that Uthman (may Allah be pleased with him) did not go to the Battle of Badr in order to attend to his ailing wife. Do any of the activities for which they go out compare to the the Battle of Badr? The rest of the stories we hear fall into the category of placing one`s trust in Allah, which is a virtue, not a vice.

 

Some of their shortcomings that we hope they will correct:

 

- Being unconcerned about clarifying the correct `aqidah (creed) so that those who consider themselves Ahlus-Sunnah do not differ in general—the introduction to the Risala al-Qairowani, for example—but, they do not study anything of the sort from what we have heard and seen.

 

- Avoiding fiqh and the study of jurisprudence, claiming that these issues arouse differences. If that were a point of consideration, fiqh would have long been abandoned and knowledge lost; of course, the scholars of Islam would never have done that. On the contrary, our hope is to gain understanding of the religion. In fact, it is from fiqh (understanding) to know what it is okay to differ about and what it is not, what we need to denounce according to Shari`ah and what we do not, and to stop at those limits. To do otherwise is to bury one`s head in the sand.

 

- They do not speak about politics. They say that politics is to leave politics. This is a clear example of fragmenting the religion. Our religion is complete and comprehensive; it includes all aspects of life, and being attentive to the affairs of all Muslims is obligatory. Islam came to govern the Ummah in the life of this world, not in the Hereafter, for that is the abode of reward in which there is no accountability. The greatest hope of the enemies of Islam is that Muslims be content with their prayers and fasting and leave the affairs of the people, their way of life and judging between them, to others.

 

- They are not active in denouncing evil acts like shirk (idolatry), bid`a (innovation), or open sin, which is not the way of the prophets, who came calling the people to goodness, and warning them of evil. Yes, this must be done with wisdom, but it is not wisdom to remain silent while we watch idolatry being perpetrated, innovation being practiced and the limits set by Allah being violated.

 

- They interpret the hadith of jihad in a way that denies it. For that reason, you do not find their presence in any region where Muslims as a whole have agreed that jihad is legitimate there.

 

- They do not advocate that those who join them be trained and educated; they only care about increasing their membership without taking care of them individually. Many other groups share this defect with them.

 

- They are affected by the deviations of some of the Sufis, like the pledge of allegiance made by the aspirant to the sheikh, and exaggeration in love and reverence for him. Likewise, they frequently mention stories of miracles that occurred to them, and dreams, which they rely upon in analysis. It has been related that some of them write amulets that contain talismans (mysterious or magical inscriptions). I have not seen anything like this with my own eyes or heard of it from reliable sources, but if the report is true, and the group confirms and admits it, this is an enormous issue.

 

- They are extremely relaxed in relating weak hadith and they rely in many countries on reading from a Tablighi book called Nisab, which is loaded with weak hadith and defective sayings.

 

Many of the ways of the group may have been decided in a particular place and time such that the founders were of the opinion that what they decided was best for that phase. However, the problem is the lack of self-evaluation inside numerous groups and assessing their work according to revelation (Qur`an and Sunnah), in terms of correctness and room for improvement.

 

As for your question about belonging to the group in Egypt, the answer is in parts:

 

1. Most people who belong to the group in Arab countries do not fall into most of the violations mentioned. They do not, for instance, read from the Tablighi book, Nisab; they read from Riyad as-Saliheen (The Gardens of the Righteous), which is a blessed book; there is no better book than it of its type.

 

2. I advise you to cooperate with them in anything that is good, but at the same time, watch out for the points mentioned above. I do not think you should become a member of the group except if there is no one better than them in your village or city in terms of knowledge and deed.

 

3. I advise you to keep company with righteous, correct scholars well-known for their knowledge and distinction in worship and piety. There is no substitute for the companionship of such men.

 

This is all I have to say on the subject and I ask Allah to guide us and them to the straight path. I also ask Him to make these words a pure effort, seeking only His countenance, and that He bestow upon the writer sincerity and upon the reader impartiality. We emphasize once again in closing, our love for our brothers in Islam from the Tabligh group and any others who work for the good of the religion and the worldwide community of believers. 

 

And Allah Almighty is more knowledgeable and from Him comes all success.