Fatwa ID: 21853
Title: Praying behind someone who says that Allah is everywhere
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 01/29/2007

Question

Peace be upon you. I am currently living in a European country and Allah has granted me the blessing of moving next to a mosque in which I pray the five obligatory prayers, and to Allah belongs all praise and grace. There are two imams for this mosque, both of whom are graduates of Deobandi schools where they studied the `aqidah (creed) of the Matridis, especially the book, al-`Aqa`id an-Nasafiya. The truth is that I used to pray behind them without asking about their `aqidah, thinking that would be the kind of deep inquiry that is forbidden, since it is permissible to pray behind any Muslim whose condition is undisclosed. However, I know a student of knowledge who used to pray with us in the mosque, then began not to come. When I asked him why he was not praying, he said that it became clear to him that these two imams both say that Allah is everywhere—in His Being, not with His Knowledge—and when he discussed this with one of them, he exploded at him saying that is the correct stance. He mentioned to him some of the scholars who say this and said that this is what he studied at the Deobandi school. So, they did not come to any resolution. The truth is, I found myself in a great dilemma, but not praying in this mosque close to the house has a lot of negative points. There is no other mosque close enough for me to pray in, and the people think badly of me because I was considered one of the well-known leaders at the mosque. It is impossible for me to inform them why I no longer come to the mosque because that would cause great fitna (conflict), especially since the mosque is run by many different nationalities. On the other hand, I think that praying behind someone who believes that Allah is everywhere is a really big problem, and Allah knows better. Finally, I would like to bring to your attention that neither imam knows that I know their beliefs on this issue and I am not ready to open a discussion with them because that would cause problems for me and for my brother who is a student of knowledge. So, what would you answer, may Allah grant you success?


Answer

In the name of Allah, all praise is for Allah, and may peace and blessing be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family and followers. To proceed:

 

Everyone whose prayer is correct for himself, is correct to follow in the prayer, and the prayer of a Muslim is correct for himself as long as he is not involved in any of the clear nullifiers of Islam that would unarguably take him out of the religion. Not praying behind an innovator or flagrant deviant is a method of calling him to account and warning others about his fitna, not because of the invalidity of the prayer itself. The Salaf did not proclaim individual followers of the Jahmiya sect to be disbelievers, even though they said that some of their beliefs were kufr (disbelief) or shirk (idolatry). On that basis, if one is able to avoid praying behind an innovator without causing greater harm, he should do so, as a protection for the Sunnah and to show disapproval to the innovator and in general. If that is not relatively easy, due to an inability to keep away from them without greater harm, or the lack of another mosque nearby, and the only other alternative is to leave the congregational prayers and pray in the house, then it would not be permissible to leave the congregational prayers for that reason. Under those circumstances, this [leaving the congregation] would be an act of the people of innovation, for the prayer is the best of all the people`s deeds. If they perfect their prayers, perfect your prayers with them, and if they do evil deeds, avoid their evil; and Allah Almighty is more exalted and more knowledgeable.