Fatwa ID: 21858
Title: "Faith is belief and action." What is the meaning of this and is secularism lesser kufr?
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 07/10/2007

Question

In truth, I am very interested in the ideas of Shaikh Salah as-Sawi, and I would like him to open the door to a discussion of several issues. May Allah send His blessing upon you.

 

Do the Murji`ah [a deviant sect] separate action from faith? Then what would it mean when we say that "faith is belief and action" (al-îmân qawl wa `amal)? But, then we take the action practically out of faith? Or are the actions of the heart a fixed part of basic faith?

 

Of course, you know what is going on concerning the issue of "ruling by other than what Allah has revealed". Is this greater kufr (disbelief) or lesser kufr? I read an article you wrote about the verdict of Islam on secularism. On that basis, wouldn`t it be oppression and deception to apply the issue of "ruling by other than what Allah has revealed"—if one believes that it is lesser kufr—to secularism?

 

May Allah bless you and send His peace and mercy upon you.


Answer

The best that has been said on this issue is that: actions are a condition for the completion of faith, with the exception of anything for which there is evidence that it is a condition for the basic validity of faith. This does not contradict our saying that "faith is belief and action", for the Murji`ah took all action out of the meaning of the word îmân (faith), just as the Khawârij [another deviant sect] included all action in basic faith, but Ahlus-Sunnah are between them [moderate and balanced]. They say that "faith is belief and action", but there are some actions that enter into the basic level of faith, there are some that complete the obligatory level of faith and there are some that perfect the preferred level of faith and it is the evidence from Shari`ah which distinguishes between this and that.

 

As for what I have to say about secularism, it is as you read in the article. The description of secularism differs from the crucial point in the issue of "ruling by other than what Allah has revealed" which the Salaf (our pious predecessors) called "kufr less than kufr", and as such, the verdict for it differs as well. Secularism is a system that rejects the authority of Divine law in principle. It is fundamentally opposed to seeking judgment from the revelation of Allah. It embodies this concept as a matter of conviction, theory and culture. It makes alliances and chooses enemies on this basis. I do not believe that anyone says that this is just a type of sin or wrong-doing or that this is what the Salaf truly referred to as "kufr less than kufr"; and Allah Almighty is more exalted and more knowledgeable.