Fatwa ID: 21987
Title: Ruling about the Quonout (humility before Allah) at dawn prayers
Category: Prayer
Scholar: AMJA Resident Fatwa Committee
Date: 10/14/2012

Question

What is the ruling about the Quonout at dawn prayers? And what is the ruling about following the Imam who is persistent on doing it?


Answer

This is an individual or independent judgment issue, in which the inconsistent person is not disavowed, but people should exchange advice on it with proofs and scientific judgments. Some Imams of the great Shari’ah schools have maintained the Quonout at dawn prayers, but the most likely that the persistence of Quonout at dawn prayers was not a sunnah of the Prophet, prayers and peace of Allah be upon him, as judged by the most correct Shari’ah scholars.

However, Quonout should be performed at calamities, until Allah The Almighty clears them away. Sa’ad Ibn Tareq Al-Ashja’i said to his father: “O, father! You have prayed behind the Messenger of Allah, prayers and peace of Allah be upon him, and behind Abou-Bakr, Omar, Othman, and Ali, may Allah be content with them, did they perform Quonout at dawn prayers? He said: “O, my son! It was not novelty at all!’, (reported by Ahmad and Al-Termizi, with a correct and authentic narration. 

            As for the Hadith narrated by Anas that the Prophet, prayers and peace of Allah be upon him used to perform Quonout in the morning until he left this worldly life, was weak, according to Scholars and experts of Hadiths. However, the Imam who performs Quonout at dawn prayers, there is no harm in following him, because he is either an independent judge or an imitator of some of the people of knowledge who maintain that judgment. There are some Hadiths and handed down sayings concerning this issue, and usually, people inconsistent in issues of individual or independent judgments are not to be disavowed.