- AR (العربية) -
- EN (English)
| Fatwa ID: | 21994 |
| Title: | Prayers shortening and combining |
| Category: | Prayer |
| Scholar: | AMJA Resident Fatwa Committee |
| Date: | 10/14/2012 |
Is it permissible to shorten prayers on traveling to and fro prison? How long is the distance legitimately determined to shorten prayers? Can one combine prayers or not?
If the distance to the prison was conventionally considered a sort of travel, one would be allowed then to follow travel permissions like prayers shortening and combining, fast-breaking, etc. However, if the distance was too short to be considered a travel, one would not subject to rulings of traveling nor enjoy its permissions.
As far as we know, no clear authentic evidence, on determining the distance, upon which prayers are duly shortened, has been reported; it is unlimited in shari`ah. Whatever is unlimited in shari`ah subjects to conventions so as to be identified; thus what conventionally is deemed as a travel, it is as such - otherwise it isn`t.
If prisoners settled down in prison, they would become residents and would not be allowed to use travel permissions as long as their cases became clear, they were sentenced and transferred to undertake their punishment. They should moreover remain patient toward the command of Allah – to whom belongs might and majesty- and may Allah find them a way out and relief them
It is worth focusing in this context on the difference between prayers shortening and combining; the former is a fixed rubric of the sunnah, and the latter is an accidental permission. The prayers of the traveler are basically to be shortened; however, the traveler combines prayers when that is needed. The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) used to shorten prayers if he got overburdened of walking. In addition, when he (the prophet) set off before the prayer time is due; he used to combine two prayers at the time of the former. However, if travelers stopped (for rest) and put down their luggage during their travel, they have to perform prayers at their due times on grounds of all texts reported on that. Allah the Almighty knows best.
