Fatwa ID: 23201
Title: Responding to a non-Muslim who sneezes by saying, "Bless you"
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 06/24/2008

Question

May the peace, mercy and blessing of Allah be upon you,

 

Is it permissible to respond to a non-Muslim who sneezes in the way he is used to by saying, "Bless you," as they say in America? It isn't a dua for mercy or forgiveness for them; it's just something they're used to saying and a Muslim could intend it as a dua for guidance for them. May Allah reward you.

 

Your brother in Islam,

Amin Hossam

Answer

In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful,

 

All praise is due to Allah and may peace and blessing be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, companions and true followers. To proceed:

 

In the hadith transmitted by Abi Dawud and classed as authentic by Al-Hakim, on the authority of Abi Musa al-Ashari, who said,

 

The Jews used to sneeze near the Prophet (may Allah bless him and grant him peace), hoping that he would say, "Yarhamukum Allah," (May Allah have mercy on you: the mandatory invocation among Muslims), but he would say, "Yahdiyakum Allah wa yuslih balakum." (May Allah guide you and improve your condition.)

 

Ibn Daqiq al-Eid said,

 

If we look at what one of the scholars of the Arabic language has said, then the word, al-tashmeet (responding to someone who sneezes), is a prayer for goodness and non-Muslims would be included in the generality of the order to respond to the sneezer. However, if we look to those who said that the word, al-tashmeet, is specifically a prayer for mercy, then they are not included. He (Ibn Hajar) said,

 

I said, "This research is from the angle of the literal meaning, but as for the technical meaning in Shari`ah, the hadith of Abi Musa indicates that they [non-Muslims] are included in the generality of the command to respond to the sneezer. However, they have a specific response which is to pray for guidance for them and that their condition improve, so there is nothing wrong with that and this is different than responding to the Muslims when they sneeze, for they are the people for whom it is obligatory to pray for mercy, as opposed to non-Muslims."

 

And Allah Almighty is the Most High and He knows best.