Fatwa ID: 23261
Title: A toddler's urine
Category: Purity
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 07/07/2008

Question

May the peace, mercy and blessing of Allah be upon you. May Allah bless you for this work and may He place it in your scales.

 

I would like to ask Your Honor if a little boy who is two years old has urinated on his pants and it dried, would it be permissible for me to let him wear them? Note that I carry him a lot. The question is also about a small amount of urine, meaning that if I wring out the pants, nothing will come out, it is only by touching or holding it that you would know it is wet.

 

The second question: If the wetness has gotten on the bed, is it permissible for me to lay down on it or does it have to be washed? Also, what if I forget where it was wet and I laid down on it and then prayed? Would I have to pray again?

 

The third question: What do you say about what people say that everything dry is pure and what is the ruling on that?

 

May Allah reward you well.


Answer

In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful,

 

All praise is due to Allah and may peace and blessing be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, companions and true followers. To proceed:

 

The rule is that a baby boy's urine should be sprinkled [with water to purify it] as long as he has not yet begun to eat food [other than breast milk]; if he has begun to eat food, it [his urine] must be washed. A baby girl's urine, on the other hand, must always be washed, whether she eats food or not. The basic principle in that is what has been transmitted by Al-Bukhari, Muslim, Abi Dawud and others, and the exact wording is that of Abi Dawud on the authority of Umm Qais bint Muhsin, that she came with a young son of hers who had not yet eaten food to Allah's Messenger (saws), so Allah's Messenger (saws) sat him on his lap and [the boy] urinated on his (saws) garment, so he called for water and sprinkled it with the water; he didn't wash it.

 

 Abu Dawud and Ibn Majah also transmitted from the Prophet (saws) that he said, "The urine of a baby girl should be washed and the urine of a baby boy should be sprinkled as long as he has not yet been fed [anything other than breast milk]."

 

Take note, however, that, if the boy's clothes have dried, the impurity does not pass from it to you, because touching dried impurities on the body or dry clothing does not affect [a person's state of purity], just as it is not affected by going barefoot into a dry bathroom when one's feet are dry because impurity is only passed on with moisture.

 

If the wetness has reached the bed, the rule is that the area of impurity must be washed by immersing it in water, however, it does not have to be wrung out and rubbed due to the hardship that would entail, for on the authority of Abi Hurairah (raa) who said, "A Bedouin man stood up and urinated in the mosque, so the people caught him, but the Prophet (saws) told them, 'Let him be and pour a large bucket of water over his urine, for you have surely been sent to make things easy, not to make things hard.'" You should also take note of what we just mentioned that, if it dries and is not soaked in water, the impurity does not pass from it to anyone who lays down on it because impurity is not passed without moisture.

 

As for your question concerning the extent to which drying purifies, or, in other words, if impurity got on the floor, the bed or a tree and was not washed, but rather was left to dry in the sun or to air-dry (or any other way), would it be pure or not?

 

The difference in this issue is well-known and there are two opinions:

 

The first opinion is that of the majority of the Maliki scholars, the Shafi`is (according to the preferred opinion of the madhhab), the Hanbalis and Zufar, from the Hanafis. They see that the ground does not become pure by drying, whether in the sun, in the air, or otherwise, because the basic principle is that impurities are removed with water, so whatever impurity falls on the floor must be removed with water, just like any other impurity.

 

Among their evidence for that:

 

The authentic narration on the authority of Abi Hurairah (raa), who said, "A Bedouin man stood up and urinated in the mosque, so the people caught him, but the Prophet (saws) told them, 'Let him be and pour a large bucket of water over his urine, for you have surely been sent to make things easy, not to make things hard.'" Imam al-Bukhari transmitted it and Imam Muslim also transmitted a similar hadith on the authority of Anas (raa). They said that the Prophet (saws) ordered them to pour water over it, and if it would have been purified just by drying, he would have left it at that.

 

The second opinion is that of Abi Hanifah and his two students [Muhammad ibn al-Hasan and Abu Yusuf], who hold that the ground becomes pure by drying, but only in respect to the prayer; tayammum (dry ablution) cannot be made with it according to their mathhab (school). There is an opinion related from Abi Hanifah himself that it is permissible for making tayammum, but this is contrary to the reliable position of Hanafi scholars. Ibn Taymiyyah chose this stance, describing it as the opinion of Imam Ahmad, and he permitted the prayer [on such ground]. They said that it is because most of the impurity had been removed from the ground and only a miniscule amount remained, so it was made pardonable due to necessity. It is also due to the fact that the nature of the ground is such that it changes things and transforms them back to its nature, becoming dirt over the course of time, so that they are no longer impure in the first place.

 

Since a person, in general, continually sees impurities here and there on the roads he uses frequently on his way to the market, the masjid and anywhere else, if these did not become pure when the traces dry up, he would have to avoid any areas in which he had seen impurity, even after the traces had gone and he would not be able to walk barefoot after that, yet it is known that the Salaf did not used to avoid that. This was mentioned by Abu Barakat Ibn Taymiyyah.  

 

Among their evidence for that from the hadith are:

 

What was authentically related on the authority of Ibn `Umar (raa): that dogs used to come and go, urinating in the masjid of Allah's Messenger (saws), and they did not used to sprinkle any of that [water]. [Related by Al-Bukhari]

 

What was related by Abi Dawud on the authority of Abi Hurairah (raa) that Allah's Messenger (saws) said, "If one of you steps in impurity with his sandals, the dust is purification for them." In another wording, he said, "If he steps in impurity with his leather socks (khuffain), their purification is dust."

 

What has come from Umm Salalah that the Prophet (saws) was asked about a woman who drags her train [of her garment] over a filthy place and then over a pure place, so he said, "What comes after it purifies it." [Transmitted by the Five]

 

It appears to us that this position is strong in terms of the rules of fiqh and in terms of its ease and gentleness on the Ummah in respect to practice. As for the hadith about the Bedouin urinating, Ibn Taymiyyah responded concerning it, saying, "What is achieved by this is accelerating the purification of the ground, which is desirable, as opposed to, if water is not poured, the impurity would remain until it is transformed." [Majmoo` al-Fatawa (21/480)]