Fatwa ID: 2644
Title: Occupying oneself with deriving rules of fiqh from the Qur`an!
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 02/14/2007

Question

1-Zakat on cattle: Seven fat calves and seven lean calves were mentioned by both the king and the king`s water-bearer; with Moses` cow, that is 29 cows, and in that is forgiveness. The word, "baqar" (cows) is mentioned three times in the Qur`an and, as we have mentioned, the word, "baqaraat" (also, cows) in the king`s dream are four, and the word, "`ijl" (calf) is mentioned ten times, so the closest sum is ten, so that`s 34, and about defining the ways to collect it, there is a description.

2-Hajj (pilgrimage): The Hajj is completed with the standing at `Arafah and praying at Muzdalifa, in agreement with the words, {So, when you have accomplished your manasik…} [Al-Baqarah 2:200] Thus, the shortest pilgrimage would be one night at Muzdalifa, which is the intent, but whoever intends to go to the Ka`bah, honors it by tawaf and staying at Mina.

3-Fasting is from four things: eating, drinking, sexual intercourse and harmful speech. It was mentioned in two consecutive verses that permitted sexual relations between spouses at night in Ramadan and confirmed that it is forbidden during the day, and the day is from the fajr to the night and the night is from the maghrib to the fajr, which is different than nahar [the other word for day] and night.

So, do you approve of this analysis so that I may send others on the subject?


Answer

In the Name of Allah, all praise is for Allah and may peace and blessing be on the Messenger of Allah, his family and followers. To proceed:

I thank you for you interest in the Glorious Qur`an and your contemplation of it. I advise you to avoid busying yourself with the likes of these analyses at this stage [of your learning]. Indeed there is another phase you must pass through first, after which you may busy yourself with analysis and exegesis thereafter. Seek knowledge from its most likely sources and at the hands of scholars; keep yourself busy in this stage and then when you have reached the level of theory and exegesis, you will discover for yourself the inherent dangers and transgressions in the likes of these types of analysis. I ask Allah for myself and for you success and accuracy.