Fatwa ID: 619
Title: Necessity and difficulty
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 05/23/2005

Question
Is necessity means the same as difficulty? And since difficulty can not be controlled except by being close to Shari`ah rules, so, what are nearly the difficulty`s controllers?

Answer

In the name of Allah the Beneficent the Merciful
Praise be to Allah, prayers and peace be upon His Messenger.

As a Fiqh rule, difficulty brings facilitation, and that if a matter becomes tight it expands. Al-Seouty has defined difficulty that brings facilitation as having two sections:

-A difficulty that is indispensable from worship, generally, such as: difficulty of cold in ablution and showering; difficulty of fasting in very hot and long days; difficulty of travel for Haj and Jihad; difficulty of pains of Shari`ah punishments; stoning of adulterers to death, beheading criminals; there is no effect for these difficulties in dropping religious duties in all times. 

-As for difficulty that could be separated from acts of worship, they are as follows:

-First: a grave and serious difficulty; such as fear for keeping lives, members, and parts` utilities, it absolutely necessitates commutation and licensing.

-Second: a light difficulty which has no effect; such as: pain in a finger; a light headache, or ill-mood. These have no effect and they are disregarded.

-Third: A medium between these two degrees, what is close of the first degree, it necessitates reduction; or to the second degree, it does not necessitate it, such as: a light fever, a light toothache, and whatever any of these is attached to any degree, it is differed upon judging it. There are no controls for these degrees except by making them close (Al-Ashbah wa-Nazaaer, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyah, Beirut, first edition, pp 80-81, 1983).