Fatwa ID: 77408
Title: Unlawful swearing 2
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 01/11/2009

Question
Our respected shaykh Dr. Salah Al-Sawi, a pleasant greeting to you. I asked a question two weeks ago about my case when I swore that it would be unlawful to me if my wife visits my family more than once a week because of the troubles that happen after each visit. You have answered that what I said is treated as an oath, therefore requires expiation of oath, but if I pay the expiation of Dhihar (i.e. one saying to his wife: you are unlawful to me like the back of my mother) that would be better as it is the safest thing to do. So, I hope from you to bear my following inquiries with patience. First, I fed 10 poor people before I nullified my oath as I was told what I said was just an oath. So, what should I do now to clear myself from this burden, especially since you have recommended that I pay the expiation of Dhihar? Second, does intention play a role in deciding whether this swearing is an oath or a Dhihar? Because wiswas overcome me while I try to remember my real intention, as I cannot recall what it was at the time. If intention is valued in such case, how can I know my intention, as I do not want to do an act before asking the people of knowledge as Allaah told us to do when He said, {“Ask the people of Dhikr, when you do not know”}. Please note that these whispers only come to me while I am very happy with my wife. So please answer me and all thanks to you, may Allaah reward you with good.

Answer
In the name of Allaah, the Benevolent, the Merciful. All praise is due to Allaah, and peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allaah, his family, companions, and those loyal to him. In your case, my beloved brother, if you intended to have your wife unlawful to you, then you need to pay the expiation of Dhihar (i.e. free a slave, if you cannot, fast two continuous months, if you cannot, feed 60 poor people). However, if you said it with the intention to scare and prevent her from disobeying, than that is different, and that requires an expiation of oath (feeding 10 poor people or clothing them). The ruling is dependent upon your intention at the time you swore. We ask Allaah to help you identify it, and know that matters are based on what one is most certain of, so act upon what seems most likely, and for anything beyond this, Allaah will forgive you by Allaah’s permission. And Allaah, the Most High, knows best.