- AR (العربية) -
- EN (English)
| Fatwa ID: | 77894 |
| Title: | Doubt during acts of worship |
| Category: | Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief) |
| Scholar: | Dr.Salah Al-Sawy |
| Date: | 02/19/2009 |
Question
Assalamu Alaykum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh, So far, we have neither come across nor heard of any proof that allows one to act upon his assumption in acts of worship, unless that happens in other matters, and Allah knows best. On the contrary, we have found proofs that forbid one to act upon his assumption, such as the hadeeth in the Sahih that the Prophet said, “Beware of conjecture! It's the most lying of speech!”, And the Ayah, {“They follow nothing but conjecture and what their own souls desire! Even though there has already come to them Guidance from their Lord!”}, and the Ayah, {“And they have no knowledge of it; they do not follow anything but conjecture, and surely conjecture does not avail against the truth at all”}. As for the proof that is used to support acting upon assumption, it is what has been narrated by Ibn Maso’ud, who reported that the Prophet said, “When one doubts something in his Salah, he should find out the correct thing…”, but in this hadeeth, to find the correct thing does not mean to certainly follow assumption. Thus, we notice that evidences that state not to follow assumption are stronger, clearer and safer than those that state to follow one’s assumption. And Allah knows best. We hope from you to answer all of that, may Allah reward you.
Answer
In the name of Allah, the Benevolent, the Merciful. All praise is due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, companions, and those loyal to him. Assumption means to be certain of one matter more than of another, unlike doubt, which means hesitation between two matters that seem to have equal possibility. So assumption here means to realize the side that is more likely to be correct. From this is when scholars say that Fiqh is based upon what is closest to certainty (i.e. most of the topics in Fiqh are based on what is most certain). It is clear that part of the proofs in Fiqh are either explicit proofs that rulings are derived from with certainty, or inexplicit proofs from which one derives rulings, based on what seems most likely to be correct but does not reach the level of certainty. Nonetheless, acting upon what is most likely the correct view that is derived from inexplicit proofs is final and agreed upon by people of knowledge. Assumption is however condemned in matters of creed, because creed can only be established upon certainty, and Allah, the Most High, condemned the disbelieving people when He reported about them in the Ayah, {“We only assume an assumption and we are not certain of it”], and in the other Ayah, {“They follow nothing but conjecture and what their own souls desire! Even though there has already come to them Guidance from their Lord!”}, and the Ayah, {“And they have no knowledge of it; they do not follow anything but conjecture, and surely conjecture does not avail against the truth at all”}. Thus, assumption (as explained) is accepted in matters that require Ijtihad in Fiqh, so that some of the people of knowledge said, while defining Fiqh, that it is to reach a ruling through assumption. And sometimes assumption is used to mean knowledge, from that is what Allah said about those who will receive their books on the Day of Judgment, {“I assumed [i.e.knew] that I will be judged”}, and the Ayah that talks about the people of Hellfire on the Day of Judgment, {“And the criminals saw the Hellfire, so they assumed that they will enter it and they have not found an escape from it”}. We ask Allah to grant you and us success. And Allah, the Most High, knows best.
