Fatwa ID: 792
Title: Torture, or infliction?!
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Salah Al-Sawy
Date: 09/13/2005

Question

In the name of Allah the Beneficent the Merciful

Is what I am going through – sexual attraction to males instead of females – a test (infliction) or torture? If it is infliction, does Allah inflict His servants with something He does not be content with? I have nothing to do with this feeling, for it is imposed on me since I was a little boy, and this is what worries me a lot. So, why does Allah test me with such an infliction and then He vows to torture me?

And if what I am going through of torture, then I wonder, what did I do when I was a little boy that Allah tests me with this shame and torture?

Isn`t this the miserable and wretched life that Allah vowed to torture with those who disobey Him? And I think I did not disobey Allah, so why do I live this miserable and shameful life? I pray to Allah, advice and counsel me what to do in order to live a normal life like anybody else. What is the view of science, medicine, and Shari`ah on my case?


Answer

In the name of Allah the Beneficent the Merciful

Praise be to Allah, prayers and peace be upon His messenger, his family, companions, and followers.

It has been said to you earlier that just controlling such desire and not manipulating it, along with fearing Allah and avoiding being involved in it and resisting it with all your possible means, then there is no wrongdoing in that, even you will be awarded by Allah for perseverance and taming it for obeying Allah, which will be a reason for attaining Allah`s content and forgiveness. The problem starts with being involved in it and responding to the lust of the self and being tempted in it.

Allah can test and inflict whomever with whatever He wants, in order that the faithful is distinguished from the dishonest, and the kind from the wicked, as He says: "And surely, We shall try you till We test those who strive hard,, and We shall test your facts", (Quran, 47:31). And what you say is not strange, for, aren`t there people who are inflicted with liking to drink liquors? Aren`t there others who are inflicted with liking to watch obscene pornography and sexually appealing music, etc? Some of those people strive for attaining Allah`s content and their ranks soar high, and others fail and are inflicted with Allah`s wrath and torture, and become liable to His Will, whether He tortures them, or forgive them, and He is All Wise, and Praise is due to Him in all cases!

Keep striving and taming yourself to attain Allah`s content, and carefully choose your companions and friends who will support and help you to be closer to Allah, and beware of being alone and being with bad friends, and keep praising Allah and reading Quran, be true in seeking Allah`s help and support, keep praying to Him, throw yourself humbly at His gates of mercy, and be sure that He will never disappoint you.