Fatwa ID: 902
Title: Working as a lawyer in courts of man-made law
Category: Basic Tenets of Faith (Belief)
Scholar: Dr.Waleed AlMeneesey,Phd
Date: 11/07/2005

Question

In the Name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful,

May the peace and blessing of Allah be upon our prophet, Muhammad, who was sent as a mercy for all the worlds.

To proceed:

 

May the peace, mercy and blessing of Allah be upon you,

 

I would like from the respected sheikh, a ruling on a rather large issue I will present to you. Let me explain:

I graduated from college (the Department of Law) in Egypt several years ago and I am currently working—off and on—as a lawyer. When I entered this department, I had no understanding about my religion. Later on, after graduating from college, I discovered what a great, enormous sin it is to judge by other than Allah`s Law. I found many laws in my country—let alone other Muslim countries—contradict Divine Law and violate its limits. So I am wondering, would it be permissible for me, when the laws in my country are as they are, to practice law with what it involves of seeking judgment by other than Allah`s Law?

 

Considering that:

 

My heart is not pleased at all with laws contrary to the pure law of Allah.
In practicing this profession, I avoid as much as possible laws that run contrary to Divine Legislation, which leads me to search constantly for other work in order to find a legitimate livelihood.
I would like to point out, finally, so as not to be unjust—that there are many laws that do not contradict Divine Legislation, such as Personal Law and many laws governing financial transactions, civil and business contracts.
After all these issues I have mentioned, with what is burning in my soul, constricting my ability to practice—in my case—considering the extent to which I avoid not implementing Islamic law, except in cases of necessity, such as restitution, getting someone their rights, or preventing oppression, would this be considered implementing and seeking judgment from other than what Allah has legislated? Also, would reading books of law and spending money on them be considered a waste of my time and money in what is displeasing to Allah? Would this reading in and of itself—even if we suppose that I would not practice this profession—if it were merely for the sake of being aware of the laws and systems being applied on us in all the affairs of our lives—whether they agree with or contradict Divine Legislation—would that be forbidden (haram)?

May Allah reward you and may the peace, mercy and blessing of Allah be upon you.


Answer

All praise is for Allah and may the peace and blessing of Allah be upon His Messenger, to proceed:

Working as an attorney is permissible in Islamic Law. It falls under the category of appointing representation in a dispute (at-tawkeel fee al-khusoomah) which has been declared permissible in the texts of all four schools of jurisprudence. Thus it is permissible for a Muslim to work as an attorney to help the oppressed and get them their rights, provided that he has enough knowledge of Islamic Law (Shari`ah) as to prevent him from cooperating in sin and transgression.

 

It makes no difference whether the attorney or the litigation is before an Islamic court or before a foreign or man-made court; what is of consequence is the permissibility of seeking judgment in that court. Thus, when it is permissible to seek judgment in a court, it is permissible to represent a Muslim litigant before it. Likewise, it is permissible for a Muslim litigant to appoint an attorney to defend him before said court. Seeking judgment from a man-made court is permissible when three conditions are fulfilled:

 

1-     If it would be unfeasible to obtain one`s right without taking the case to a court of man-made law, as in the situation of an opponent who refuses to seek judgment from Islamic Law, or who sought judgment from an Islamic court, but refused to implement the Islamic ruling.

2-     One must not take more than the right established for him in Islamic Law; if the court of man-made law rules in excess of one`s Islamic right, one must not take from his opponent what exceeds his right.

3-     One must maintain hatred in one`s heart when he goes to seek judgment there.

 

Should these conditions be met, seeking judgment from man-made courts becomes permissible, and as such, the attorney defending someone in the right [not someone he knows is guilty] in order to help him, to restore for him his right as established in Islamic Law and to prevent injustice, he will be rewarded and thanked. Likewise, studying man-made law at the university in the Department of Law with the intention to help the oppressed and get them their Islamic rights is permissible on condition that he has enough Islamic knowledge and faith (iman) that would prevent him from being tempted by the man-made laws and that would prevent him from getting the correct Islamic ruling mixed up with the false ruling from man-made legislation. And from Allah is all success.